Brother TN258 and Brother TN258XL Toner Cartridges
Brother TN258 and Brother TN258XL toner cartridges provide standard and high-yield options to suit different office printing volumes. Standard-yield Brother TN258 cartridges are suitable for everyday document printing, while high-yield Brother TN258XL cartridges reduce replacement frequency during heavier workloads. Genuine, premium compatible and multi-pack options are available to help manage ongoing printing costs. Our 4.8 Google rating reflects the reliable cartridge quality and performance our customers receive.
Printers Compatible with Brother TN258 and Brother TN258XL Toner Cartridges
Expected Page Output and Replacement Cycles
Brother TN258 and Brother TN258XL toner cartridges provide two yield levels for different office printing volumes. Standard-yield Brother TN258 black, cyan, magenta and yellow cartridges each print up to 1,000 pages. High-yield Brother TN258XL black cartridges print up to 3,000 pages, while Brother TN258XL cyan, magenta and yellow cartridges each print up to 2,300 pages. These yields are measured in accordance with ISO/IEC 19798, although actual output varies according to page coverage, print settings and document complexity.
| Cartridge Number | Type | Colour | Page Yield | Cost Per Page |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| TN258BK | Standard | Black | 1,000 | $0.14 |
| TN258C | Standard | Cyan | 1,000 | $0.16 |
| TN258M | Standard | Magenta | 1,000 | $0.16 |
| TN258Y | Standard | Yellow | 1,000 | $0.16 |
| TN258XLBK | High Yield | Black | 3,000 | $0.061 |
| TN258XLC | High Yield | Cyan | 2,300 | $0.084 |
| TN258XLM | High Yield | Magenta | 2,300 | $0.084 |
| TN258XLY | High Yield | Yellow | 2,300 | $0.084 |
Cost Per Page = Total Cartridge Price ÷ Page Yield (at 5% coverage). Prices based on Genuine cartridges.
Genuine vs Compatible Cartridges
Genuine Brother toner cartridges are manufactured specifically for supported Brother printers, while premium compatible cartridges provide a more affordable option for everyday office printing. Using compatible cartridges does not automatically remove your rights under Australian Consumer Law. Ink Depot compatible cartridges are covered by a money-back performance guarantee if they do not install, register or perform as expected. Read our genuine vs compatible cartridges guide to compare the available options.
Best Way to Stock These Cartridges
Brother TN258 cartridges are suitable for lighter or occasional printing, while high-yield Brother TN258XL cartridges reduce replacement frequency during busier office workloads. Workplaces producing mainly invoices, reports and correspondence may benefit from keeping an additional black cartridge available. Businesses printing regular colour presentations, charts or marketing materials may prefer a complete colour set or multi-pack.
Compatible cartridges are covered by a money-back performance guarantee. If you order the wrong cartridge, review the available options through our returns policy. Free delivery applies on orders over $99, with products dispatched from distribution centres in Sydney, Melbourne, Brisbane, Adelaide and Perth. Browse our complete range of Brother toner cartridges for other Brother printer models.
Pro Tip
Supported printers can use Brother TN258 and Brother TN258XL cartridges at the same time. For example, you can install a high-yield Brother TN258XL black cartridge while standard-yield Brother TN258 cyan, magenta and yellow cartridges remain in use. This allows each cartridge capacity to be selected according to your workplace printing requirements.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why does my printer display a Replace Toner message?
The printer monitors toner usage and displays a replacement message when an installed cartridge reaches its expected replacement point. Actual toner consumption varies according to page coverage, print density and document type. Confirm that the correct cartridge has been installed and follow the printer instructions when replacing it.
Can I use Brother TN258XL cartridges in a Brother HL-L3240CDW?
Yes. The Brother HL-L3240CDW supports both standard-yield Brother TN258 and high-yield Brother TN258XL toner cartridges. You can also use different supported yields at the same time, such as a Brother TN258XL black cartridge with Brother TN258 colour cartridges.
Why are faint vertical lines appearing after replacing a toner cartridge?
Faint vertical lines may be caused by a cartridge that is not seated correctly, loose toner residue or contamination around the drum unit or corona wire. Remove and reinstall the affected cartridge, then follow the printer maintenance instructions for cleaning the corona wire. If the issue continues, inspect the toner cartridge and drum unit or contact Ink Depot for assistance.
